Elementi vs Modeno: Which Fire Pit Brand is Best for Your Backyard?
When you’re shopping for the best outdoor fire pit, two names always seem to rise to the top: Elementi and Modeno. They come from the same trusted manufacturer, but they’re designed with different buyers in mind.
Elementi is for those who appreciate premium finishes, powerful performance, and designs that turn an outdoor space into a true showpiece. Modeno takes a more budget-friendly approach, offering stylish and durable fire pits that won’t stretch your wallet.
From my experience, choosing between them isn’t just about the price tag — it’s about how long your fire pit will last, how well it fits your space, and how much enjoyment it will bring you year after year. In this guide, we’ll put them side-by-side, comparing design, pricing, performance, and real customer reviews, so you can feel confident picking the brand that’s right for you.
Brand Background, Market Positioning, and Who Each Fire Pit is Best For
Elementi
The Elementi fire pit line has a way of combining eye-catching, sculptural design with serious outdoor performance. It’s no wonder it’s considered one of the top fire pit brands out there. You’ll find everything from sleek, modern rectangles to rustic, stone-inspired bowls — each one built to be a functional statement piece.
I’ve seen Elementi fire pits become the centerpiece in high-end residential backyards, boutique hotel courtyards, and even designer-led outdoor living projects. With premium GFRC concrete, stainless steel burners, and meticulous attention to finish quality, they’re made for those who want their outdoor fire pit to look as good in ten years as it does the day it’s installed. For homeowners and designers alike, it’s a brand that delivers both style and staying power.
Modeno
The Modeno fire pit brand is like Elementi’s approachable sibling, offering modern concrete designs at a friendlier price point, without skimping on the solid construction you expect from a quality fire pit. Modeno keeps things simple with a focused catalog, featuring versatile shapes and finishes that fit seamlessly into just about any space.
It’s a smart starting point if you want the style and durability of concrete without paying extra for the high-end polish, broader fire pit size selection, or luxury design details you’ll see in Elementi’s lineup. For many of my customers, Modeno strikes that perfect balance — good looks, reliable performance, and a price that leaves room in the budget for other outdoor upgrades.
Key Takeaways
- Elementi offers premium finishes, larger sizes, and bundled accessories for a complete outdoor fire pit setup.
- Modeno delivers stylish GFRC concrete fire pits at more budget-conscious price points.
- Both brands use durable GFRC concrete and 304 stainless steel burners for longevity and weather resistance.
- Heat output ranges from 45,000–60,000 BTUs, with Elementi typically offering higher-end performance.
- Choose Elementi for luxury aesthetics and all-in-one packages, or Modeno for value, simplicity, and easier portability.
Fire Pit Prices and Value: Comparing Features, Quality, and Cost
When you put an Elementi fire pit side-by-side with a Modeno fire pit, the first thing most folks notice is the price difference. Elementi models usually run between $1,000 and $2,000+, while Modeno keeps the bulk of its designs in the $600 to $1,000 range.
That’s why Modeno has become a go-to for budget-conscious buyers who still want the strength of GFRC concrete and the dependability of stainless steel burners. With Elementi, that higher price tag often comes from more intricate finishes, larger formats, and those premium design touches that really make a fire pit stand out in a luxury setting.
For example, best-sellers like the Elementi Granville Fire Pit Table come loaded with premium touches, a durable stainless steel burner, push-button spark electronic ignition, and plenty of table surface space for serving or styling. It’s the kind of piece designers and homeowners choose when they want their fire pit to be a true focal point.
Modeno, on the other hand, shines when it comes to delivering exceptional value on the essentials. Take the Modeno Roca Fire Table. It features a reliable battery-powered ignition, compatibility with both propane and natural gas, and a one-year warranty, all while keeping the price comfortably under $1,000. For many of my customers, that’s the sweet spot between style, function, and budget.
Accessories can make a big difference in the overall value you get from a fire pit. With Elementi, you’ll often see premium upgrades included or available as part of a package — things like tempered glass windscreens, stainless steel lids, and matching tank enclosures that elevate both style and convenience.
RELATED: Elementi Hampton vs Elementi Granville
Design, Craftsmanship, and Material Quality in Modern Outdoor Fire Pits
Both Elementi and Modeno fire pits are built from glass-fiber reinforced concrete (GFRC) — a material I’ve always appreciated for its strength, weather resistance, and ability to mimic natural stone textures without the heavy weight. That means you’re getting a fire pit that can handle year-round outdoor conditions and still look great season after season.
Elementi leans toward bold, statement-making designs that naturally become the centerpiece of a backyard or patio. Best-selling models like the Elementi Manhattan and Elementi Metropolis feature clean, modern lines with a strong presence.
You’ll usually see them in timeless, neutral finishes like slate black, ash grey, and beige — colors that blend beautifully into high-end landscapes while still standing out as focal points.
Modeno, while using the same solid manufacturing quality, focuses more on minimalist, approachable aesthetics. The Modeno Roca and Modeno Aurora fire tables, for example, have smooth, rounded silhouettes and understated tones like light grey or dark slate.
This makes them versatile enough to complement both modern patios and rustic decks without overpowering the surrounding décor. And here’s a fun fact: research shows that gathering around a fire can actually help lower blood pressure and promote relaxation, giving your fire pit benefits well beyond just warmth.
Both Elementi and Modeno share some core features that make them reliable choices:
- 304 stainless steel burners for rust resistance.
- Push-button battery ignition (with Elementi also offering electronic ignition on select models).
- Propane and natural gas compatibility, often with conversion kits included.
Elementi tends to offer more tabletop space and built-in features, making it great for entertaining. Modeno keeps things compact — perfect for small patios, balconies, or tighter outdoor layouts.
Heat Output, Burner Performance, and Efficiency for Outdoor Gatherings
When it comes to outdoor heating, both Elementi and Modeno know how to deliver reliable warmth. Their stainless steel burners and well-tuned flame designs put out a steady, comfortable heat that’s perfect for cooler evenings. Most models sit in the 45,000–60,000 BTU range, which is just right for gathering 5–8 people around the fire.
Elementi models like the Granville and Metropolis tend to land on the higher end, pushing up to 60,000 BTUs on propane setups. That extra output comes in handy for larger patios or breezier spots where the wind can steal a bit of warmth. Plus, their wide burner pans create a big, dramatic flame that’s as much about ambiance as it is about heat.
READ Guide on Firepit BTU 101
Modeno models, like the Roca and Aurora, usually run 50,000–55,000 BTUs. While that’s a touch lower on paper, the more compact design means the heat stays concentrated — perfect for smaller patios, side yards, or rooftop setups where efficiency often matters more than raw firepower.
Fuel flexibility is another thing both Elementi and Modeno get right:
- Standard 20 lb propane tanks work right out of the box.
- Natural gas conversion kits are available for a permanent hard-line setup.
- Adjustable flame controls let you set the mood or save on fuel when you don’t need full heat.
It’s a setup that works just as well for weekend entertainers as it does for homeowners wanting a low-maintenance, year-round fixture.
Ease of Setup, Assembly, and Everyday Use for Homeowners
Both Elementi and Modeno fire pits are designed for quick, plug-and-play setup — minimal tools, fast ignition, and no complex assembly. Just connect your propane hose or use a natural gas conversion kit (best installed by a pro) and you’re good to go.
They share a push-button battery ignition with adjustable flame control, though Elementi’s dials feel a bit smoother. Modeno models are often lighter — the Roca is about 105 lbs vs. the Elementi Granville at 150 lbs, making them easier to move.
Elementi usually includes more in the box, like lava rock, a PVC cover, and sometimes a matching tank cover. Modeno includes lava rock and a cover, with other accessories sold separately at lower prices.
Choose Modeno for portability, Elementi for the most complete starter package.
Real-Life Reviews: What Homeowners Are Saying
Elementi Fire Pit Reviews
“It exceeded my expectations when I unpacked it. It looks amazing! We’ve been using it a lot and it gives a nice heat. We’ve received many compliments.” — Orson Garrett on the Elementi Lunar Bowl.
“More than expected, beautiful addition to our outdoor patio.” — Kris Baldock on the Elementi Granville.
Homeowners consistently praise Elementi’s blend of artistry and performance—making it a standout for those seeking both beauty and warmth in an Elementi fire pit review.
Modeno Fire Pit Reviews
“Great outdoor fireplace for the patio. Gives out good heat and a nice fire for the price. Would definitely recommend.” — S. Fulton on the Modeno Nantucket.
Modeno owners highlight reliability and value, with many citing strong performance and satisfaction for its price—common themes in Modeno fire pit reviews.
Warranty Coverage, Customer Service, and Brand Reputation
Elementi and Modeno come from the same parent company, so you’re getting the same build process and quality control standards with either choice. Both brands include a 1-year limited warranty covering manufacturing defects in materials and workmanship.
Where Elementi edges ahead is in its premium positioning — higher-end models often go through more extensive third-party testing and additional quality inspections before they ever ship.
Customer service is a strong point for both, especially when purchased through Fire Pit Surplus. Our customers frequently mention quick email responses, transparent shipping updates, and proactive problem-solving.
Owners of the Elementi Granville often note fast parts replacement and responsive support, while Modeno Roca buyers highlight clear setup guidance and smooth communication.
In terms of market trust, Elementi is widely recognized as one of the top fire pit brands, especially among designers, landscapers, and high-end homeowners. Modeno, while newer to the scene, has built a loyal following for delivering stylish, durable fire pits at more accessible price points — a go-to for buyers who want quality without overspending.
And here’s something worth noting — research shows that outdoor spaces with fire elements can actually help reduce stress and improve mood. So whichever brand you choose, you’re getting more than just heat — you’re adding a little peace of mind, too.
How to Decide Which Fire Pit Brand Fits Your Budget and Style
Choose Elementi if:
- You want premium finishes like refined concrete textures and high-capacity burners.
- A wider range of shapes, sizes, and fuel options matters to your design vision.
- You value bundled accessories that let you get started right out of the box.
Choose Modeno if:
- You’re after a modern concrete fire pit at a more approachable price point.
- Portability is a priority — their lighter builds are easier to move.
- You’re okay with purchasing accessories separately to save on upfront costs.
Quick Decision Matrix
| Priority | Best Choice |
|---|---|
| Luxury look & finish | Elementi |
| Budget-friendly quality | Modeno |
| More design options | Elementi |
| Lighter & easier to move | Modeno |
| Complete starter package | Elementi |
Frequently Asked Questions About Elementi vs. Modeno Fire Pits
1. Are Elementi fire pits better than Modeno?
Elementi fire pits offer premium finishes, higher BTU output, and more design variety, making them ideal for luxury spaces. Modeno delivers similar durability at a lower price, perfect for budget-conscious buyers seeking quality.
2. Do both Elementi and Modeno fire pits use GFRC concrete?
Yes. Both brands use glass-fiber reinforced concrete (GFRC), valued for its strength, weather resistance, and stone-like texture without heavy weight — ensuring long-lasting durability even in year-round outdoor conditions.
3. Can Elementi and Modeno fire pits run on natural gas?
Both brands are propane-ready out of the box and offer natural gas conversion kits for versatility. For safety, efficiency, and warranty protection, a professional should handle permanent hard-line installations.
4. Which fire pit brand is better for small patios?
Modeno fire pits are generally lighter and more compact, making them ideal for small patios, balconies, or rooftop spaces. They provide the same GFRC durability as Elementi but with a footprint that’s easier to position.
5. Do Elementi fire pits come with accessories?
Most Elementi models include lava rock, a PVC cover, and sometimes a matching tank cover. Modeno includes lava rock and a cover, with accessories sold separately — often at lower prices for added budget flexibility.
Final Thoughts on Choosing the Right Fire Pit
Both Elementi and Modeno deliver excellent performance, safety, and style, so it’s less about which is “better” and more about which one matches your budget, aesthetic, and how you plan to use it.
Elementi shines with premium craftsmanship, a wide range of designs, and accessory bundles that make it easy to get started in style. Modeno, on the other hand, offers dependable, great-looking fire pits at prices that won’t stretch your budget.
Either way, you’re looking at top fire pit brands known for durability and strong customer support. My advice? Take a look at our financing options and explore the Elementi Fire Pit Collection or the Modeno Fire Pit Collection to find the one that’s just right for your space.
