Modern Blaze vs Fire Pit Surplus: Reviews, Pricing & Where to Buy a Fire Pit

When you're comparing Modern Blaze vs Fire Pit Surplus, you're really looking at two retailers built for different spaces.

Modern Blaze has carved out a strong niche in indoor electric fireplaces, wall-mounted units, built-in inserts, and chimney-free designs that work well for apartment remodels and modern living rooms.

Fire Pit Surplus takes a wider approach, offering a curated lineup of outdoor fire pits, fire tables, fireplaces, wood stoves, and patio heaters from 30+ trusted brands.

And the demand for outdoor fire features keeps growing. According to the Hearth, Patio & Barbecue Association (HPBA), 83% of outdoor hearth product owners also have BBQs or outdoor kitchens, showing that fire pits are now central to how patios are designed and used.

In this guide, we'll compare these two retailers across brands, pricing, delivery, support, and more so you can choose with confidence.

Quick Takeaways

Meet the Retailers

Modern Blaze

Modern Blaze is a family-owned retailer founded in 2014, headquartered in Miami, FL, with a mailing address in Russiaville, IN. They specialize in chimney-free, ventless fireplace solutions, electric fireplaces, water vapor units, ethanol models, and ventless gas options.

Their catalog leans heavily toward indoor applications, carrying brands like Modern Flames, Dimplex, Touchstone, Napoleon, Amantii, and Dynasty.

They claim 19,000+ happy customers and operate primarily online. If you're remodeling a living room, bedroom, or apartment and need a fireplace that doesn't require a chimney or gas line, Modern Blaze has built a focused catalog for exactly that.

Contact: (866) 713-2399

Timing: Mon–Fri 9 AM–9 PM ET, Sat 10 AM–2 PM ET

Fire Pit Surplus

Fire Pit Surplus is a Wyoming-based retailer founded in 2020, built to serve homeowners, designers, and commercial buyers looking for outdoor heating and fire features. The product range covers outdoor fire pits, fire tables, fireplaces, wood stoves, and patio heaters from 30+ U.S.-based brand partners, each one curated for design quality and durability.

Most of my customers appreciate that many Fire Pit Surplus models ship with bundled accessories: covers, lava rock, burner kits, so there's no guessing what you need to add to your cart. And with 7-day-a-week expert support, you can call any day to talk through sizing, fuel type, or design questions.

Contact: (888) 671-4611

Timing: 9 AM–9 PM PST, 7 days/week

Brands & Product Lineup

Fire Pit Surplus: Curated Outdoor + Indoor Heating

• Modern gas fire pits: Elementi, Elementi Plus, Modeno, Pyromania Fire
• Artisan and premium designs: Prism Hardscapes, The Outdoor Plus, Pottery Works, Stonelum, Slick Rock Concrete, Fire Pit Art
• Patio heaters: Bromic Heating, Infratech, Schwank, Sunglo
• Wood stoves: Drolet, Osburn, Buck Stove, Englander, Century Heating
• Fireplaces: Napoleon, Empire Comfort Systems, Dimplex

Modern Blaze: Indoor Electric & Ventless Focus

• Electric fireplaces: Modern Flames, Dimplex, Touchstone, Napoleon, Amantii, Dynasty
• Water vapor: Dimplex Opti-Myst, AFireWater
• Gas (ventless): Montigo, Empire
• Outdoor (limited): Select patio heaters and outdoor fireplaces

Fire Pit Surplus goes deep on outdoor fire features with dedicated brands, from budget-friendly Modeno fire pits built with durable GFRC concrete and push-button ignition to premium artisan pieces.

Modern Blaze goes deep on indoor electric and ventless options. Where they overlap is Dimplex, which gives us a direct price comparison.

Product Snapshot: Dimplex Revillusion 30" (RBF30)

Pricing, Value & What's Included

Same product, two different prices. That $165 difference on a single electric fireplace insert adds up, especially for designers or contractors ordering multiple units for a project.

Modern Blaze Pricing

• Electric fireplaces: $300–$5,500+ depending on size, brand, and features.
• Best Price Guaranteed: Modern Blaze advertises price matching on qualifying products.
• Accessories: Most units ship as standalone; accessories sold separately.
• Financing: Affirm (3/6/12-month plans, some with interest).

Fire Pit Surplus Pricing

• Entry-level fire pits: $600–$1,200 Modeno and smaller Elementi models make a great starting point.
• Mid-range: $1,500–$3,000 design-focused brands like Prism Hardscapes and EcoSmart Fire.
• High-end: $3,500–$6,000+ premium artisan designs from The Outdoor Plus and Bobe Water and Fire.
• Financing: Interest-free installment splits + PayPal Pay Later.

Discount Codes & Promotions

Modern Blaze runs regular electric fireplace sales and backs purchases with a Best Price Guaranteed policy. Finding a consistent Modern Blaze discount code online can be hit-or-miss; most savings come through their listed sale prices rather than promo codes.

Fire Pit Surplus takes a different approach with seasonal holiday sales (Memorial Day, Labor Day, Black Friday), bundle discounts on accessories, and competitive everyday pricing.

Shipping, Delivery & Lead Times

Modern Blaze offers free shipping across the contiguous U.S. via FedEx, UPS, or freight carriers depending on product size. Delivery timelines vary by item, and freight damage must be reported within 5 days of receipt.

Fire Pit Surplus provides free shipping on orders over $199 to the lower 48 states. In-stock items process within 1–3 business days and typically arrive in 3–10 days. For larger fire features, Fire Pit Surplus offers an optional backyard delivery upgrade. Your fire pit gets placed right where you want it, not just left at the curb.

Insurance & Protection

Fire Pit Surplus includes freight insurance on shipments and gives you a 48-hour inspection window after delivery. If anything arrives damaged, the Fire Pit Surplus team handles the claim directly, no back-and-forth between you and the carrier.

Modern Blaze requires freight damage to be reported within 5 business days. The claims process is more formal, and you're responsible for documenting the freight receipt and filing through their support team.

Website Experience & Buying Process

Modern Blaze is well-organized for its niche. Their Modern Blaze electric fireplace catalog has strong filter options by size, brand, and installation type. Product pages include Description, Specs, Features, What's In The Box, Installation details, and a Request a Quote option, helpful for larger indoor projects.

Fire Pit Surplus keeps things clean and visual. Product pages include detailed specs, lifestyle images, a "Why Buy From Us" trust tab, and transparent pricing with no hidden fees. The blog section doubles as an educational hub: shopping guides, brand comparisons, and YouTube videos help first-time buyers make confident decisions.

For custom quotes, Fire Pit Surplus typically turns requests around within 24–48 hours with a dedicated B2B sales rep. Modern Blaze offers a Request a Quote feature on product pages, though turnaround may vary on larger orders.

Customer Support

Reviews, Returns & Warranty

Reviews

Fire Pit Surplus reviews hold a 4.4-star rating across verified reviews. Customers consistently praise fast shipping, clear communication, and knowledgeable reps who help with sizing and design decisions. Phrases like "arrived ahead of schedule" and "team was incredibly helpful" come up frequently.

"Excellent experience from start to finish. The fire pit arrived faster than expected and the team answered every question I had." - Fire Pit Surplus reviewer

Modern Blaze reviews are generally positive, with roughly 4.5 stars across BBB-listed locations. Buyers highlight competitive pricing on electric units and fast shipment on smaller products.

"Good selection of electric fireplaces and fair pricing. Delivery was on time." - Modern Blaze customer via BBB

Return Policy

Both retailers offer a 30-day return window. At Fire Pit Surplus, the customer pays return shipping, but there's no restocking fee on most products (some brand-specific exceptions are noted on the product page).

Modern Blaze also requires the customer to cover return shipping, and restocking fees may apply. For freight items, Modern Blaze's 5-day damage reporting window is tighter than the 48-hour inspection-and-claim process at Fire Pit Surplus.

Warranty

Fire Pit Surplus lists manufacturer warranties clearly on each product page and handles warranty claims on the buyer's behalf, so you're working with Fire Pit Surplus directly, not chasing down the manufacturer.

Modern Blaze provides manufacturer warranty information and directs buyers to product manuals for coverage details.

Payment, Financing & Secure Checkout

Both retailers run PCI-compliant checkout with standard payment options. The main difference is financing: Fire Pit Surplus offers Bread Pay financing with mostly interest-free installment splits, while Modern Blaze partners with Affirm for structured monthly plans that may carry interest depending on the term.

Trade Programs & Bulk Orders

Fire Pit Surplus runs a dedicated B2B Trade Program built for designers, contractors, architects, and hospitality buyers. You get tiered pricing discounts, a dedicated sales rep, priority order processing, unlimited swatches, and fast approvals (typically within 48 hours).

Fire Pit Surplus also specializes in commercial fire pits for hotels, resorts, and restaurants, ready-to-install units that simplify large-scale outdoor living space projects.

Modern Blaze mentions serving contractors, designers, and architects, but doesn't prominently advertise a formal trade program with tiered pricing or dedicated rep assignments.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Modern Blaze located?

Modern Blaze is headquartered in Miami, FL, with a mailing address in Russiaville, IN. Founded in 2014, they're a family-owned retailer that operates primarily online, specializing in indoor electric and ventless fireplace solutions.

What are the downsides of electric fireplaces?

Electric fireplaces provide supplemental heat only, typically 5,000–9,000 BTUs, and produce a simulated flame effect rather than a real fire. They're not designed for outdoor use. If you need serious outdoor heating, a gas fire pit delivering 40,000–60,000+ BTUs is a better fit.

Is Modern Flames a good brand?

Yes, Modern Flames is a manufacturer (not a retailer) known for premium electric fireplaces like the Landscape Pro and Orion series since 2008. Don't confuse Modern Flames the brand with Modern Blaze the retailer. For outdoor fire features, brands like Elementi and The Outdoor Plus are the leaders.

Does Modern Blaze offer discount codes?

Modern Blaze runs regular sales on electric fireplaces and advertises a Best Price Guaranteed policy. However, consistent Modern Blaze discount code availability is limited; most savings come through their posted sale prices rather than standalone promo codes.

Final Verdict

Both retailers serve their buyers well within their specialties. Modern Blaze has built a strong catalog for indoor electric and ventless fireplace shoppers, if that's your project, they're a solid option with good product variety.

But for homeowners, designers, and trade professionals looking for outdoor fire pits, fire tables, or a full-spectrum heating solution, Fire Pit Surplus consistently delivers better value. Lower pricing on shared products like the Dimplex 30" insert.

The choice is clear: unless your project is strictly an indoor electric fireplace, Fire Pit Surplus provides the most direct path to where to buy a fire pit, or fireplace, or stove with confidence.