Fireplace Vs Wood Stove: Deep Dive Comparison
The roar of the flames. The warmth that radiates through the air. There's nothing quite like a cozy fire on a cold winter night. Whether you're sitting in front of a fireplace or a wood stove sipping a nice glass of wine, these heating sources offer some serious benefits. But which one is right for you?
Both options have perks and deciding which is right for you can be challenging. But ultimately, a wood stove is the clear winner on what matters most.
Preview: A large masonry fireplace may increase the value of your home as a desirable focal point but can be impractical for heating purposes. A wood stove is a more practical choice for heating your home and is more energy efficient.
This post will dive deeper into the differences between fireplaces and wood stoves to help you make an informed decision.
The Differences Between A Wood-Burning Fireplace & A Wood-Burning Stove
What Is A Wood Burning Fireplace?
A wood-burning fireplace is a traditional fireplace attached to a chimney that has been used for nearly a millennium to keep cold homes warm and add a cozy ambiance to a living space.
A typical fireplace is constructed with brick or stone masonry built to appeal—a chimney centrally located in the house vents the smoke.
While burning wood in a fireplace can be an attractive and charming focus of attention in your living space, it is not the best choice for a heat source.
Fireplaces are typically inefficient at heating a home since they heat only the small area surrounding the fireplace. About 90% of the fires output goes right up and out the chimney.
What Is A Wood Burning Stove?
On the other hand, a wood-burning stove is a freestanding appliance typically made of cast iron or steel designed to heat a larger area more efficiently. Wood stoves have been around for hundreds of years and have seen many modern technological advances.
They are an excellent choice for those who want to heat their homes with firewood since they are more energy efficient than burning wood in a fireplace.
The best-selling wood stove brand is Drolet, and they offer many different glass door models to suit any style and budget.
Wood stoves provide homeowners with a practical and efficient way to heat their family home.
If you're looking for a heat source that is both beautiful and functional, a wood stove is the clear choice.
Wood Burning Stoves and Wood Burning Fireplaces Compared
So which option is best for you – a fireplace or a wood stove? The following are the pros and cons of each to help you make your decision:
Pros of Fireplaces:
- Beautiful focal point in a living space
- Great for a comforting ambiance
- More aesthetically appealing than wood stoves
- Can increase the value of your home due to its charm and aesthetic appeal
Cons of Fireplaces:
- They are not very practical for warming larger areas of a house, as they only heat the small area in a room around the fire
- Not very energy efficient: a large amount of wasted heat
- Not environmentally friendly: inefficient combustion creates greenhouse gases
- It may require costly repairs
- Requires significant maintenance to use safely
Pros of Wood Stoves:
- High efficiency, resulting in less wasted energy
- High heat output, which makes them a good choice for heating an entire house
- Fewer emissions than wood fireplaces, making them a more eco-friendly option to burn logs for heat
- More flexibility in the placement, as wood stoves do not require a built-in chimney
- Better safety as the firebox is sealed shut with a door and contained.
Cons of Wood Stoves:
- Significant upfront investment in purchasing the stove
- Upfront installation costs can be high
- Annual and monthly maintenance for optimal performance
- Dangerous if not used safely (fires, burns, smoke)
- Hot to the touch (young children may not know any better)
If you want to install a wood fireplace from scratch, you can expect to pay upwards of $30,000 in installation costs. After the initial investment, you will need regular maintenance and repairs from professionals to keep your fireplace functioning properly. This can be a hassle in the long term.
A wood stove is a more affordable option, with installation costs averaging around $2,000. Once installed, the maintenance to keep it running at peak performance will cost you less and can be done by yourself. You only need to worry about soot and creosote buildup every few weeks.
While both options are a great way to stay warm and cozy, wood stoves offer significantly higher efficiency than wood fireplaces.
According to the EPA, fireplaces are the most inefficient heaters. With a typical wood-burning fireplace efficiency rating of only 25%, wood stoves can achieve an efficiency rating of up to 80% or more, making them the better choice for your pocketbook and the environment. This is especially helpful when using a single heat source to heat your entire home.
When it comes to fuel costs, wood stoves are a more cost-effective option than fireplaces. This is because wood stoves are 3X as efficient as fireplaces, saving homeowners money on their overall firewood bill.
In fact, installing a wood stove in your home can help you save up to $1,500 every year in heating costs!
The best type of firewood for max heat output is dry, seasoned hardwood such as oak, maple, or beech, which can be purchased from your local firewood retailer or by searching “cord wood” on Facebook Marketplace.
A cord of seasoned hardwood logs cut, split, and delivered has an average price of $350 per cord in northern US states. Even better, if you live on a wooded lot with acreage, you can do the work yourself and heat your home for free!.
You can burn cheaper softwood like poplar or birch, but hardwood creates less creosote, burns longer, and burns hotter.
An EPA-certified wood stove may consume between 3-6 full cords of wood in a single season, depending on usage, climate, and heating requirements, while a fireplace may consume 8-12 full cords of wood in a single season. That’s double the amount of firewood needed per year!
While a traditional wood burning fireplace creates a dreamy ambiance and atmosphere. the heat output of a wood stove is typically 75% higher, making it a much more practical option for heating large areas of a home.
According to BobVila.com, 90%+ of the heat generated in a traditional wood fireplace goes right up and out the chimney. On the other hand, a wood stove is specifically designed to retain and radiate the heat with specialized venting and heat retaining materials.
Since wood stoves and fireplaces are hot to the touch, they can be dangerous for young children if they are not used safely. It is important to keep children away from the stove or fireplace and never leave them unattended in the same room with a burning fire. Also, ensure a working fire extinguisher is nearby in case of emergencies.
In addition, EPA-certified wood stoves generally come with safety instructions. They are equipped with a chimney pipe temperature gauge to prevent accidental fires, sit on a hearth to prevent sparks from burning the floor, and feature a locking door to keep the fire contained.
Therefore, when it comes to safety and efficiency, wood stoves are the better choice for maintaining a warm and cozy room.
How to Improve Fireplace Safety
If you want to improve the safety of your fireplace, there are several measures you can take.
- Regular cleaning and maintaining your chimney
- Installing a fan or blower system to reduce toxic fumes
- Installing a fire screen or heat-proof glass doors to prevent sparks from getting out
- Installing carbon monoxide detectors
Environmental Impact Of Wood Stoves And Fireplaces
Let’s face it, burning a wood fire in any form is not the most carbon neutral way of keeping your family warm in the cooler months.
According to the EPA, one of the most significant environmental impacts of fireplaces is their high levels of greenhouse gas emissions, which are up to 8X higher than wood stoves.
This is mainly due to their inefficient combustion process, which results in large amounts of CO2 and other waste materials being released into the atmosphere contributing to climate change.
Further, wood stoves are better at reducing emissions than fireplaces due to their higher efficiency and built-in ventilation systems, making them a more sustainable option for heating your home with firewood.
Extra Features of a Wood Stove
Wood stoves offer several extra features that set them apart from fireplaces, including:
- Ability to cook and boil water on top of the stove.
- High-efficiency rating of up to 80% or more.
- Built-in ventilation systems that help improve air quality and prevent overheating.
- Stone or concrete hearth to prevent fires
- Locking doors to keep the fire and sparks safely contained within the firebox.
- Ability to control the size and intensity of the burn with drafting and vent controls.
- Lower cost to keep your home warm throughout the season, especially when compared to other heating options like electric or gas.(See Penn State’s Analysis)
- Comforting log cabin-like aesthetic
Whether you're looking for a way to save money on your energy bills or want a more environmentally-friendly way to keep your home nice and toasty, wood stoves are a great option that offer lots of extra features and benefits.
Take it from me, a homeowner in Maine who has used fireplaces and wood stoves to heat my home my entire life - if you're looking for an efficient, cost-effective way of staying warm this winter, switch to a wood stove today!
Wood Burning Fireplace Vs. Wood Burning Stove FAQs
Which is better, a wood-burning stove or a fireplace?
Overall, wood-burning stoves are better than wood fireplaces for heating your home. They offer significantly higher efficiency and heat output, making them a more cost-effective and environmentally-friendly choice for your home.
Can you insert a wood stove in a fireplace?
Yes, it is possible to insert a wood-burning stove into a fireplace. Many modern wood-burning stoves are designed to be installed in an existing fireplace. Some models even come with flue systems that can be connected directly to your chimney.
Is a wood-burning stove cheaper than a fireplace?
Yes, a wood-burning stove is typically cheaper than a fireplace. This is because wood stoves are more efficient at converting fuel into heat, meaning you need less wood to heat your home. Additionally, wood stoves typically require less maintenance than fireplaces, reducing the cost of using them to keep your home nice and toasty.
The Final Verdict - Fireplace Or Wood Stove?
When it comes to the choice of an older wood fireplace or a modern wood stove, there are many factors to consider. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, but when it comes down to it, wood stoves are generally the better choice to stay warm all winter. They offer higher efficiency, safety features, and environmental benefits, making them more sustainable than fireplaces.
Are you looking for a safe and efficient way to heat your home this winter? Check out our wood stove selection and see which one best fits your needs. Our guide to the best wood stoves can also help you find the perfect model for your home.
Thanks for reading!